Novartis shares plunge 13% after muscle drug trial fails

Earnings Impact 4
โดย Seeking Alpha·CHUS·Read original
Summary · why it matters

Novartis shares fell 13% in premarket trading on Tuesday after its late-stage trial for the muscle-wasting drug del-desiran failed to meet primary endpoints, marking the company's third drug trial setback in a week and putting the stock on track for its worst trading day ever. The failure also dragged down other biotech stocks, with Dyne Therapeutics falling about 30%, Sarepta Therapeutics dropping 16%, and NewAmsterdam Pharma down 12%, as concerns spread across the sector. Novartis said its global phase III HARBOR study, testing del-desiran in patients with myotonic dystrophy type 1, did not demonstrate statistically significant improvement versus placebo on measurements of hand opening time. The company is evaluating the full dataset and will engage with health authorities to determine the next steps. Del-desiran is one of three antibody oligonucleotide conjugate therapies added to Novartis's neuromuscular pipeline through its roughly $12 billion acquisition of Avidity Biosciences last year. Despite the setback, Novartis maintains its 5-6% five-year sales CAGR guidance for 2025-2030.

Impact on assets 4

Biotech & Genomic Medicine▼ · 3 stocks
Novartis AG
NOVN
▼ NegativeTechnologyrelevance

Novartis's phase III HARBOR trial for del-desiran failed to meet primary endpoints, its third trial setback in a week.

Dyne Therapeutics Inc
DYN
▼ NegativeCompetitionrelevance

Dyne Therapeutics fell about 30% as the Novartis muscle-drug trial failure spread concerns across the biotech sector.

Sarepta Therapeutics Inc
SRPT
▼ NegativeCompetitionrelevance

Sarepta Therapeutics dropped 16% amid sector-wide fallout from Novartis's failed del-desiran trial.

Theme Impact 1

Off-coverage companies 1

Avidity BiosciencesPrivate▼ Negative
Technologyrelevance

Del-desiran was one of three antibody oligonucleotide conjugate therapies acquired via Novartis's ~$12 billion Avidity Biosciences acquisition, so the trial failure undermines that pipeline asset.

Related news

United StatesChinaDenmarkFrance
▼

Sanofi, Novartis and Novo Nordisk Lead Week of Multi-Billion-Dollar Healthcare Deals

A Delaware federal judge on Monday rejected requests from Pfizer, BioNTech and Moderna to dismiss lawsuits filed by Bayer's Monsanto unit over their use of US Patent No. 7,741,118, a patent related to mRNA technology, with Judge William Bryson saying the companies failed to prove the patent was invalid or not infringed by their COVID-19 vaccines. Sanofi agreed to a deal worth up to $8B, including $1B upfront, with Regeneron to jointly develop four long-acting immunology therapies, led by the clinical-stage IL-13 monoclonal antibody REGN20423. China's Abogen Biosciences signed a licensing and option agreement with Novartis worth up to $7.8B, comprising a $575 million upfront payment and up to approximately $7.2 billion in potential milestone payments if all options on all programs are exercised, covering an exclusive worldwide license to Abogen's lead asset ABO2203. Jiangsu Hengrui Pharmaceuticals agreed to license global rights to its experimental obesity drug HRS-1596 to Novo Nordisk in a deal worth up to $2.6B, with $300M upfront and the transaction expected to close in Q4 2026. Meanwhile, the S&P 500 Health Care Sector Index slipped 2.66% for the week, with Incyte down 6.93% and Regeneron down 6.71% among the top decliners, while McKesson rose 4.11% and Cardinal Health gained 3.67%.
About megatrends
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › RNA Therapeutics ▼Capital
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › mRNA Platforms ▼Capital
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › Autoimmune & Immunology Therapeutics ▲Capital
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › Metabolic, Diabetes & Obesity ▲Capital
NOVN.SW · Demand · Positive Novartis signed a licensing and option agreement with Abogen worth up to $7.8B covering ABO2203.
SAN.PA · Demand · Positive Sanofi agreed to an up-to-$8B deal with Regeneron to jointly develop four long-acting immunology therapies.
Abogen Biosciences · Demand · Positive Abogen Biosciences licensed its lead asset ABO2203 to Novartis in a deal worth up to $7.8B.
22UA.XETRA · Regulation · Negative Delaware judge rejected BioNTech's motion to dismiss Monsanto's mRNA patent lawsuits over its COVID-19 vaccine.
600276.CG · Demand · Positive Hengrui licensed global rights to its obesity drug HRS-1596 to Novo Nordisk for up to $2.6B, with $300M upfront.
MRNA · Regulation · Negative Delaware judge rejected Moderna's motion to dismiss Monsanto's mRNA patent infringement lawsuits over its COVID-19 vaccine.
Read original ↗
Seeking Alpha·8hRead more →
United StatesCanadaUnited Kingdom
▼

HSBC Upgrades Target, Citi Downgrades Moderna in Week of Analyst Calls

Wall Street analysts issued a slew of rating changes this week, led by HSBC's upgrade of Target to Buy from Hold with a price target raised to $190 from $125, citing a turnaround "gaining momentum." Citi downgraded Moderna to Sell from Neutral, calling the valuation "unjustifiable" after the biotech rallied more than 222% since a Phase 3 win for its personalized cancer shot intismeran autogene, and cut its price target to $60 from $80. Deutsche Bank downgraded PepsiCo to Hold from Buy, while Goldman Sachs upgraded Occidental Petroleum to Buy from Neutral with a $69 price target, up from $63, and double-downgraded Tourmaline Oil to Sell from Buy with a C$49 target, cut from C$59. Wells Fargo upgraded Consolidated Edison to Overweight from Equal Weight with a $118 target and BP to Overweight from Equal Weight with a $57 target, while downgrading ExxonMobil to Equal Weight from Overweight with an unchanged $182 target. Morgan Stanley reinstated Nvidia as its top pick in the semiconductor space.
About megatrends
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › mRNA Platforms ▼Capital
Read original ↗
Seeking Alpha·1dRead more →
United States

Wells Fargo Starts Design Therapeutics at Overweight on Friedreich Ataxia Program

Wells Fargo initiated coverage of Design Therapeutics with an overweight rating, citing the company's Friedreich ataxia candidate DT-216P2 as having potentially best-in-disease functional improvement based on results from the RESTORE-FA study released in May. The bank set a $26 price target, implying roughly 112% upside based on the October 1 close. Analyst TianQi Hang wrote that the May update showed pharmacokinetics look good, and that blood-FXN protein, muscle-mRNA data, plus an early mFARS signal further de-risk the platform. Hang estimates that the blood FXN protein increase seen after 6 weeks can translate to at least a 2-point mFARS change, and said that if the drug kinetics sustain for 12 weeks, which he believes they will, DT-216P2 could deliver best-in-disease functional benefits. He assigns DT-216P2 a 60% probability of success, with peak sales of approximately $600M in the US and approximately $900M outside it. If approved, DT-216P2 would compete against Biogen's Skyclarys, also known as omaveloxolone, and Hang sees it gaining a peak share of the FA treatment market of 30% in the US and 20% ex-US.
About megatrends
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › Rare Disease ▲Competition
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › Neuroscience & Neurodegenerative ▲Competition
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › RNAi / Antisense Oligonucleotides Competition
Biotech & Genomic Medicine › RNA Therapeutics ▲Competition
Read original ↗
Seeking Alpha·2dRead more →